The Dilemma of Hospitality: Revisiting Indonesia’s Policy on Handling Refugees Under International Law

Ganesh Cintika Putri

doi:10.30641/ham.2022.13.113-130

The Dilemma of Hospitality: Revisiting Indonesia’s Policy on Handling Refugees Under International Law

Ganesh Cintika Putri

Abstract

Presidential Regulation No. 125 of 2016 is the first regulation that provides a normative framework to manage refugees and asylum seekers in Indonesia. However, many scholars believe that this regulation is simply an institutionalization of several existing informal practices, and it does not introduce any substantive changes to ensure refugee protection. This paper analyzes the content of the Presidential Regulation, including its background, structure, wording, and its aims. In addition, this study identifies the limits of the regulation in fulfilling, protecting, and respecting human rights based on the international human rights instruments. This article contends that the Presidential Regulation portrays what I call dilemma of hospitality. It reflects on the one hand, the regulation welcomes the refugees by providing mandates to the authorities to rescue those stranded at sea and to provide accommodation during their stay. On the other hand, the regulation implies a kind of distrust to the refugees—treating them as a threat, limiting their movement, and forbidding them from work. The dilemma by and large affects the effective fulfillment of the rights of the refugees. This study offers some policy recommendations.

Keywords

refugee; ICCPR; ICESCR; hospitality; Presidential Regulation 125/2016

Full Text:

PDF

References

Adiputera, Yunizar, and Atin Prabandari. Addressing Challenges and Identifying Opportunities for Refugee Access to Employment in Indonesia. Yogyakarta, 2018.

Baker, G. Policising Ethics in International Relations. London: Routledge, 2011.

Bidinger, Sarah. “Syrian Refugees and the Right To Work: Developing Temporary Protection in Turkey.” Boston University Internatinal Law Journal 33 (2015).

Committee on Economic Social Cultural Rights. CESCR Statement: Duties of States towards Refugees and Migrants under the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 2017.

———. General Comment No. 20 (2009): Non-Discrimination in Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (Art.2, Para.2 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights)., 2009.

Derrida, Jacquess. Adieu to Emannuel Levinas. California: Stanford University Press, 1999.

Douzinas, Costas. The End of Human Rights . Hart Publishing, 2000.

Harvey, Gemima. Beyond Limbo, Building Lives: Livelihood Strategies ofRefugees and Asylum Seekers in Java, Indonesia, 2019.

Hugo, Graeme, George Tan, and Jonathan Napitupulu. “Indonesia as a Transit Country in Irregular Migration to Australia.” In A Long Way to Go: Irregular Migration Patterns, Processes, Drivers and Decision-Making, edited by Marie McAuliffe and Khalid Koser, 167. ANU Press, 2017.

Jalil, Aslam Abd. “The Right to Work Can Empower Refugees in Malaysia’, The Conversation.” Last modified July 5, 2019. Accessed April 15, 2021. https://theconversation.com/the-right-to-work-can-empower-refugees-in-malaysia-119666.

Kilibarda, Pavle. “Obligations of Transit Countries under Refugee Law: A Western Balkans Case Study.” International Review of Red Cross 99, no. 1 (2017): 211.

Liauw, Hindra. “Menlu Tak Ingin Penampungan Rohingya Tarik Pengungsi Lain.” Kompas, June 10, 2015.

Louise Berg, Mette, and Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh. “Introduction to the Issue.” Migration and Society 1, no. 1 (December 1, 2018): 1–6.

McNevin, Anne, and Antje Missbach. “Luxury Limbo: Temporal Techniques of Border Control and the Humanitarianisation of Waiting.” Int. J. Migration and Border Studies 4, no. 2 (2018): 12–34.

Missbach, Antje. Stalemate: Refugees in Indonesia Presidential Regulation No 125 of 2016, 2018.

———. “Substituting Immigration Detention Centres with ‘Open Prisons’ in Indonesia: Alternatives to Detention as the Continuum of Unfreedom.” Citizenship Studies (2020).

Morse, Ian. “‘Open Prison’: The Growing Despair of Refugees Stuck in Indonesia.” Al Jazeera, March 4, 2019.

Prabaningtyas, Raden Ajeng Rizka Fiani. “Indonesia and The International Refugee Crisis: The Politics of Refugee Protection.” Journal of Indonesian Social Sciences and Humanities 9, no. 2 (December 31, 2019): 131–146.

Purkey, Anna Lise. “A Dignified Approach: Legal Empowerment and Justice for Human Rights Violations in Protracted Refugee Situations.” Journal of Refugee Studies 7, no. 2 (2013): 260–281.

Shianto, Vinsensius. “Employing Refugees in Indonesia: Is It Possible?” Jakartapost, June 11, 2018.

Still, Judith. Derrida and Hospitality: Theory and Practice. Edinburgh, 2010.

Tobing, Dio Herdiawan. “Indonesia Refugee Policy Is On Right Track’.” The Jakarta Post. Last modified January 24, 2019. Accessed April 17, 2021. https://www.thejakartapost.com/academia/2019/01/24/indonesia-refugee-policy-is-on-right-track.html.

UNHCR. UNHCR Monthly Statistical Report: Indonesia , January 2020.

Zieck, Marjoleine. “Refugees and the Right to Freedom of Movement: From Flight to Refugees and the Right to Freedom of Movement: From Flight to Return Return.” Michigan Journal of International Law 39 (2018).

Tehokeu v Darma Susila (2020).

Yousufi Falsification Case (2019).

Zakarea Fraud Case (2021).